Coming of age in samoa, first published in 1928, is a book by margaret mead based upon youth in samoa and lightly relating to youth in america. The characterization of mead and her cohort relies almost exclusively on blums archival mining. Coming of age in samoa by margaret mead has made a significant impact in the ethnographic and anthropological field by comparing two. Coming of age in samoa by margaret mead, paperback.
Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed, citizens can change the world. Mead, then a student of frank boas the father of american anthropology and ruth benedict, was schooled in the concept of cultural determ. Margaret mead, an american anthropologist, wrote the book coming of age in samoa. In 1925, franz boas, the father of american anthropology, faced. Coming of age in samoaessay 1 running head coming of. Chapter 6 margaret meads coming of age in samoa and. Coming of age and constructing imagined futures in samoa. Coming of age in samoaessay 1 running head coming of age. Margaret mead and coming of age in samoa different aspects of culture define people over a period of time. The apparently readily comprehensible descriptive discourse in margaret meads famous ethnographic study coming of age in samoa 1928 cas presents a discursive challenge that is greater than one might expect from a book that has gained a wide readership. Through it, people were given a look at a society not affected by the problems of 20th century industrial america.
Theory in your face margaret meads coming of age in samoa. And as an observer of the sexual development of teenage girls, pipher is a faithful heir to meads samoan fieldwork and studies. Traditionally samoan teenagers are encouraged to have sex but the church has changed behavior. Derek freemans 1983 critique of margaret meads coming of age in samoa has prompted one of the most heated debates in recent anthropological memory. Margaret meads coming of age in samoa, which was actually her doctoral a novel by margaret mead pages 9. Here i argue that a careful reading ofcoming of age shows quite a different picture.
Coming of age in somoa margaret mead s coming of age in samoa, which was actually her doctoral dissertation, was compiled in a period of six months starting in 1925. It is only human nature that we see differences in culture and ourselves when thrown into a melting pot, a mix of multicultures in which we live today. It is concluded that, while mead appears to have engaged in some inappropriate generalizations to the rest of samoa from the small island of tau, freemans counterevidence to support his claim that adolescence on tau would. Understanding the discourse of early childhood education. Margaret mead and the great samoan nurture hoax psychology. Margaret meads coming of age in samoa and boasian culturism an historical analysis in 1925, franz boas, the father of american anthropology, faced by what he called the difficulty of telling what part of our behavior is socially determined and what is generally human, arranged for his. An analysis of margaret meads the coming of age in samoa. Pdf this paper presents an analysis of the meadfreeman controversy with a focus on meads claim that coming of age in 1920s samoa was accomplished. Freeman then turns to one of meads major conclusions. Coming of age in somoa margaret meads coming of age in samoa, which was actually her doctoral dissertation, was compiled in a period of six months starting in 1925.
Coming of age in samoa by margaret mead, paperback barnes. Coming of age and constructing imagined futures in samoa and. After meads death freemon wrote a scathing critique of her book coming of age in samoa which claimed that she had totally misunderstood samoa and to make a long story short this proved that a more sociobiological version of anthropology was needed. Analysis of margaret meads coming of age in samoa bartleby. Margaret mead 19011978 began her remarkable career when she visited samoa at the age of twentythree, which led to her first book, coming of age in samoa. Coming of age in samoa is a book by american anthropologist margaret mead based upon her. Title coming of age in samoa author margaret mead editors williams morrow and company 1928 chapter 1 summary this was the introductory chapter for coming of age in samoa, in which a researcher chooses a samoan child to watch and see her grow from an adolescent to a full fledged adult. Although meads research in samoa came with a lot of controversy and criticism, it did shed some light into why american adolescent face great emotional and psychological stress. In this pioneering ethnography,4 published in 1928, mead does more than normalize data.
Analysis of margaret meads coming of age in samoa 1227 words 5 pages. Margaret meads coming of age in samoa, which was actually her doctoral dissertation, was compiled in a period of six months starting in 1925. Thus, meads analysis of adolescent conflict is upheld in the comparative literature on societies worldwide. Coming of age in samoa is a book by american anthropologist margaret mead based upon her research and study of youth primarily adolescent girls on the island of tau in the samoan islands. Through theoretical analysis, and in relation to the notorious. In 1983, five years after margaret meads death, harvard university press published a book by derek freeman 19162001, an anthropology professor at the australian national university, which challenged the accuracy of meads findings in coming of age in samoa. The goal was to demonstrate that culture is relative, rather than concrete.
The coming of age in ethnography in 1928, american anthropologist margaret mead wrote her groundbreaking doctoral dissertation, coming of age in samoa. Her book coming of age in samoa published in 1928 based on her studies of adolescent behavior in a polynesian society became a bestseller and brought its author to the forefront of american anthropology, where she would remain for half a century. Children and youth in history margaret mead, coming of. The book details the sexual life of teenagers in samoan society in the early 20th century, and theorizes that culture has a leading influence on. Chapter 6 margaret meads coming of age in samoa and boasian. Understanding the discourse of early childhood education in. Coming of age in samoa 1928 and sex and temperament in three primitive societies 1935 were remarkable books, contributing to the dissolution of evolutionary anthropology.
Through theoretical analysis, and in relation to the notorious meadfreeman controversy, we seek to contribute to understanding cas as. In the introduction to the perennial classic edition of coming of age in samoa, she places mead as the matriarch of family therapy and child and adolescent development. Coming of age in samoa a psychological study of primitive youth for western civilisation. Another, more subtle function has been a moral one. Margaret meads coming of age in samoa purported to provide ethnographic proof that nurture was the dominant factor in. Margaret meads coming of age in samoa, which was actually her doctoral. An analysis of coming of age in samoa, a novel by margaret. Very little sounds like the anthropological writing of boas or other american anthropologists that preceded mead. Essay on coming of age in samoa 1705 words bartleby. Coming of age of human adaptability studies in samoa. With the publication of coming of age in samoa, margaret mead brought to her audience in 1928 a readable vision of adolescent sexuality derived from nine months of fieldwork on the island of tau the work begins, the life of the day begins at dawn, or if the moon has shown until daylight, the shouts of the young men may be heard before dawn from the hillside. Margaret mead, anthropological theory flashcards quizlet.
In 1928, martha mead published coming of age in samoa, an anthropological work based on field work she had conducted on female adolescents. However, her most important work in samoa was on courtship patterns in adolescents. In both volumes she theorizes that culture is a leading influence on psychosexual development. Margaret mead quotes author of coming of age in samoa. The author had to resolve a combination of significant conflicting values affecting the roles of women in the american society. Coming of age in samoa 1928 launched meads career as an anthropologist, which was reaffirmed with the 1930 publication of new guinea. Coming of age in samoa coming of age in samoa is a very different type of anthropological work than harris, and is primarily an account and analysis of the fieldwork she conducted in samoa mead 2001. In meads book that became a best seller and unleashed a storm of controversy, she argued that it was cultural factors rather than biological forces that caused adolescents to experience emotional and psychological stress.
Freemans refutation of meads coming of age in samoa. Margaret meads famous ethnographic study coming of age in samoa 1928. The general objective of meads research was aimed at the role of different cultural patters in human character. The book details the sexual life of teenagers in samoan society in the early 20th century, and theorizes that culture has a leading influence on psychosexual development. Mead relegated to a special chapter her evidence on girls whose adolescence involved conflict. An analysis of coming of age in samoa, a novel by margaret mead pages 9. Coming of age in samoa is an important book for two reasons. Analysis of margaret meads coming of age in samoa 979. The following discussion is an indepth exploration of margaret mead and jennifer coles ethnographies that examines the overlaps between their theoretical perspectives and ethnographic authority, in addition to the broader themes of adolescence. She went on to become one of the most influential women of our time, publishing some forty works and serving as curator of ethnology at the american museum of natural history as well as president of major scientific associations. The book make an interesting study of a culture thats.
Samoans reminisce about meads probing intimate questions. Yet even meads defenders have generally accepted the view that she saw samoa as a romantic paradise. Sep 19, 20 margaret meads coming of age in samoa critique the impetus for margaret meads fieldwork in samoa, very much championed by the antiuniversalist sentiments of her mentor, franz boas, was to challenge and dispute the notion of an overarching, predetermined psychological development of the individual. The ethnographic perspective coming of age in samoa. Critique of margaret meads coming of age in samoa margaret mead began her fieldwork in samoa under the instruction of franz boas. She also surmises that the socalled civilized world could learn a lot from socalled primitives. Some sections seem to come from a travelogue, others from a novella. Other articles where coming of age in samoa is discussed. Coming of age in samoa margaret mead harper academic. Coming of age in samoa by margaret mead 401 words 123.
Meads experience in samoa was challenging due to her focus on removing the existing traditional beliefs proposed by freud regarding female psychological development. Mead alleged that adolescence in samoa was the age of maximum ease and there were none of the stresses and storms, the conflicts and troubles that characterize coming of age in western civilization. Mead, 1928, one of the most influential anthropological works of the twentieth century stocking, 1989, margaret mead analyzed the way young girls grew up in samoa in the mid1920s and, within this context, the cultural patterns of early childhood education. One can only imagine what it must have been like for margaret mead as she traveled half way around the world in. On august 31, 1925, margaret mead arrived in pago pago, american samoa to conduct ethnographic research on a particular problem. Through it, people were given a look at a culture not influenced by the difficulties of 20th century industrial america.
On august 31, 1925, margaret mead arrived in pago pago, american samoa to conduct ethnographic research on a. Meads teacher, franz boas, insists that she study adolescent girls if she goes to american samoa. This paper presents an analysis of the meadfreeman controversy with a focus on meads claim that coming of age in 1920s samoa was accomplished with relative ease. Coming of age in somoa margaret meads coming of age in samoa, that was her doctoral dissertationthat was published in a span of six months starting in 1925. Mead points out in her preface to this morrow quill edition, it was the first piece of work by a serious professional anthropologist written for the educated layman in which all the paraphernalia of scholarship designed. Coming of age in samoa 2 individuals, in spite of their culture, encountered. Jan 07, 2018 coming of age in samoa is stylistically interesting in that it targets a general audience. Coming of age in samoa, margaret meads psychological study of youth in a primitive society, is today recognized as a scientific classic. Margaret mead s coming of age in samoa purported to provide ethnographic proof that nurture was the dominant factor in child development and adolescence. A different type of anthropological work than harris 1278 words 6 pages. Meads findings seemed to show that youth in samoa are taught to grow together and strengthen the confidence of each other. Children and youth in history margaret mead, coming of age. It is concluded that, while mead appears to have engaged in some inappropriate generalizations to the rest of samoa from the small island of tau, freemans counterevidence to support his claim that adolescence on tau.
In these works, mead represented the primitive as having something valuable to teach the civilized about reforming its present. In 1928, martha mead published coming of age in samoa, an anthropological work based on field work she had conducted on female adolescents in samoa. Coming of age in samoa is stylistically interesting in that it targets a general audience. Publication date 1928 topics girls, children samoan islands, women samoan islands, adolescence, samoan islands social life and customs publisher new york. It is concluded that, while mead appears to have engaged in some inappropriate. Coming of age of human adaptability studies in samoa 129. Her findings were published in coming of age in samoa 1928, a vivid, descriptive account of samoan adolescent life that became tremendously popular. Most readers of the blog will be familiar with this debate. Ceremonies in samoa coming of age essay 2300 words. Oct, 2010 most readers of the blog will be familiar with this debate. The book clearly indicates her belief in cultural determinism, a position that caused some later 20thcentury anthropologists to.
951 127 513 105 891 1068 559 1377 586 993 153 125 191 524 1166 438 682 678 1562 875 1514 258 1042 1316 355 1458 1122 541 1171 356 1456 1333 822 1229 347 629 365 1405 793